DRB approves replacement in kind of 45th Avenue side porch, requires operable shutters

Architect Keith Buff (S17) described removing a failing 10×20 side porch dating to the early‑20th century and rebuilding a like‑for‑like porch down to the slab with new wrapped columns, stone floor, and standing‑seam metal roofing on the new porch. The board discussed whether the porch was historic and concluded it was not architecturally significant, noting past alterations and non‑original balustrade details.

Board member S3 moved to approve the plans with two conditions: (1) the proposed shutters be sized so they would cover the windows if closed and be installed with proper operable hardware, and (2) Miratek trim be mounted smooth‑side out. The motion was seconded and passed; Leslie DeCarlo recused herself due to proximity.