Legislature approves sale of Old County Library to DeWitt House Associates for $925,000 amid preservation objections

Members debated whether the county should hold the Old County Library property for possible future public use or authorize its sale for housing. Robert Lynch, speaking during public comment, urged the Legislature to pause and reconsider the sale and described the building as undervalued and deserving preservation: “Please reconsider. Please reject the DeWitt House proposal by Travis Hyde Development Group,” he told the Legislature.

Committee reports and developer presentations preceded a lengthy debate about massing, materials, parking, Lifelong’s use of a community room, affordable housing expectations and whether the sale should include reverter language. Architect Graham Gillespie described design changes made after city review and said the project would include energy measures such as green roof components and electric‑based heating. He noted rent ranges he expected — one‑bedroom units “in the neighborhood of… $1,600” and larger units higher — and that the developer aimed at “mid‑market” rather than subsidized affordable housing.

Leslyn moved the primary resolution to declare the site no longer needed for public use; other resolutions covered the SEQR negative declaration and authorization of sale. The Legislature passed the package on a recorded roll call (sale resolution passed by an 11–3 vote). The finance director’s amendment directs sale proceeds into the capital reserve account upon receipt.