Retired FBI agent Scott Smith appears for reappointment to Idaho Commission of Pardons and Parole

Scott Smith appeared before the Senate Judiciary & Rules Committee for consideration of his reappointment to the Idaho Commission of Pardons and Parole and outlined his professional background and approach to parole decisions.

Smith told the committee he graduated from San Diego State in 1982 and later served in the FBI for roughly three decades with postings overseas. Describing parole hearings as "individual hearings," Smith said, "The resident, in my opinion, sets the stage ... they've completed their programming and showed a willingness to take additional programming," adding that commissioners engage in frank, independent discussions before reaching an opinion.

Senators asked Smith how he balances public safety and rehabilitation. To Senator Shippey he said he does not have a single fixed approach and emphasized reviewing sentencing, disciplinary records, program completion and the individual’s willingness to change. In response to Senator Keiser regarding so‑called rider programs for offenders who committed crimes against minors, Smith said stricter application and supervision are appropriate in cases involving predators and toddlers, and that decisions should be made case-by-case.

Chair Senator Lakey told Smith the committee typically votes on appointments at the next meeting; no vote was taken at this hearing.