Commission continues COA for chimney at 535 West Harvey Ave pending engineer report

Staff presented File PLCA2026100And52, a continued Certificate of Appropriateness request for 535 West Harvey Ave, and summarized an engineering report that found the clay brick masonry fireplace and chimney exhibiting multiple failure modes and pulling away from framing. The property, built circa 1919, is a contributing structure within the York‑Chester Historic District. Staff said the report notes mortar deterioration, buckling, and differential settling that will continue to progress without intervention.

Owner and applicant Wes Forbus told the commission, "My address is 535 West Harvey Avenue," and confirmed he had not discussed a rebuild option with the engineer and intends to remove the chimney and infill the wall to match the house. Commissioners debated whether the standards (which identify chimneys as character‑defining features) require replacement where feasible and whether the engineer had been asked to consider rebuilding. After discussion the commission voted to continue the item to the August 27 regular meeting and instructed staff that, if a supplemental engineering report arrives sooner, staff may notify the chair and call a special meeting within 48 hours for possible earlier action.