Packed public hearing shows residents split over Dunedin Causeway jet-ski ban

A near-continuous queue of speakers filled the commission chamber July 23 to address a proposed ordinance that would prohibit launching motorized watercraft from the Dunedin Causeway.

Speakers in favor of the ban emphasized ecological recovery and public safety. Megan Colby of the Suncoast Sierra Club said the 2024 temporary restrictions produced measurable habitat recovery: “Since motorized launches were temporarily restricted... we’ve seen a remarkable rapid recovery of critical seagrass habitats and marine life along the shoreline.” Kim Begay of the Clearwater Audubon Society cited a SwiftMud seagrass survey and singled out seagrass as critical habitat for fish, scallops, and shorebirds.

Opponents framed the causeway as an affordable access point and stressed equity and rescue benefits. Susan O’Brien, who identified herself as a multi‑generation Dunedin resident, told the commission that banning launches would “punish a whole bunch of people” who cannot afford marina slips. Several residents, including Nathaniel Combs and Jason Hernandez, urged the city to instead pursue education, enforcement, launch fees, designated attendants, or resident permits so responsible users retain access without damaging the shoreline.

Business and industry voices called attention to economic impacts and volunteer cleanup efforts. Nick Wedell, general manager of a local powersports dealer, described community cleanup rides and said personal watercraft produce secondary revenue and jobs. Others noted that some launches can be unsafe when mixed with swimmers and paddlers and said a combination of management tools might reduce conflict without a full ban.

Public safety and enforcement were recurring themes. Speaker accounts included citations issued for operating in motor-exclusion zones and at least one fatality related to watercraft operations cited during staff presentations. Both sides urged stronger enforcement and more trash receptacles; opponents pointed to displaced launching to other ramps as a likely outcome if beach launches are closed.

The commission heard highly personal testimony across ages and incomes; commissioners acknowledged the split and emphasized the need to balance safety, environmental stewardship and public access before voting the ordinance through its first reading (4–0). The record will be open again at the ordinance’s second reading on Sept. 3, 2026.