Cheryl Davis Cole, founder of Beacon Staffing in Aberdeen, and Carolyn Evans, an attorney, told a packed Harford County "Level Up" seminar that hiring a first employee requires planning both the job and the paperwork.
"People don't fail jobs. Unclear jobs fail people," Cole said, urging business owners to start by listing the tasks and skills they expect from a new hire and to decide whether the role should be full-time, part-time or a contractor.
The presenters emphasized practical recruiting and onboarding steps: write a clear job description, post consistently on job boards (including Maryland Workforce Exchange), use structured interview questions for all candidates, verify references and consider skills testing. They recommended preparing a first-day schedule, assigning a mentor for questions, and setting 30/60/90-day goals so both employer and employee understand expectations.
On the legal side, Evans walked attendees through essential forms and compliance deadlines. Employers must complete the I-9 no later than an employee's first day of work (not before the candidate accepts the job), inspect original documents rather than photocopies, and retain completed forms for three years after hire or one year after termination, whichever is later, she said. She also reviewed federal W-4, Maryland's MW507 and the state's new-hire reporting window (within 20 days of hire), and urged employers to provide written pay notices as required under Maryland's wage-transparency rules.
Evans also warned about classification and wage-and-hour risks. Employers should not assume that a worker is a contractor without applying IRS, state and common-law tests; misclassification can lead to wage claims, back taxes and penalties. She summarized basic Fair Labor Standards Act reminders: pay at least the state minimum wage (as noted in the seminar) and overtime at time-and-a-half for hours over 40, and ensure salaried employees meet exemption tests before withholding overtime.
On background checks and screening, presenters advised outsourcing drug screens and criminal-background checks to specialists because of legal rules governing those processes. Cole recommended budgeting for hiring costs — from free job posts to paid listings, pre-employment screens, referral bonuses and onboarding hardware or software — and said small firms often benefit from a payroll service once they have multiple employees.
The presenters covered interview limits and consent: limit questions to job-related items to avoid discrimination and obtain explicit consent before audio-recording interviews; videotaping may be permissible with appropriate consent to audio capture.
They closed by reminding attendees that documentation — signed expectation sheets, consistent policies, posted labor-law notices and well-kept payroll records — is the employer's best defense in disputes. "Work with a professional," the presenters advised, naming accountants, attorneys and insurance agents as key advisers for first-time employers.
The seminar was presented with sponsorship from Harford County agencies and local business organizations; presenters said they will share the slide deck and resources used in the session.