Council continues damage claim from San Yance Valley Horseback Rides for legal review

Bob Sweeney, owner of San Yance Valley Horseback Rides, presented a claim at the May 14 meeting seeking reimbursement and rent abatement after construction activity at the nearby Williamsen property disrupted his business.

Sweeney said city contractors began work without adequate notice, altered parking access and that his horses subsequently became ill; he reported one pony died and estimated $112,000 in lost revenue plus $60,000 in related losses from a cancelled event. He told the council he followed city protocols but felt the claims process had not produced a satisfactory result.

Council members questioned whether the matter could become litigated and asked staff and the assistant city attorney to review the CEQA documents, insurance coverage and the JPIA denial. The assistant city attorney recommended more time for legal review; council agreed to continue the item to allow city legal staff to examine the materials and report back. Sweeney said he did not want litigation but sought a practical resolution to restore his business operations.

The matter was continued to a future meeting so the city attorney and staff can review records, CEQA materials and correspondence before the council considers potential remedies or action.