Commission denies wholesale window replacement; suggests restoration and storms for 2236 Rivermont

Sharon and Bill Wheeler told the commission their 1910 Rivermont home has 23 drafty windows and that they sought double‑pane Pella replacements to improve energy performance and usability. Sharon said high winter heating costs drove their request and that many windows are painted shut or have damaged storm windows.

Commissioners said the commission’s guidelines prefer repair of original windows and replacement only when original material is severely deteriorated. A commissioner outlined less invasive alternatives: storm windows (interior or exterior), restoration of weights and cords, reglazing, and use of historically sympathetic aluminum‑clad wood sashes only where the original is missing or irreparably damaged. Staff and commissioners recommended exploring restoration contractors and demonstrated‑based solutions rather than wholesale replacement.

The board voted to deny the wholesale replacement application and encouraged the Wheelers to pursue window restoration in place and weatherization options (interior/exterior storms) that maintain the house’s historic character. Staff offered to share a contractor list and administrative pathways for staged restoration work.