Board restores agricultural status to horse-breeding property, discusses statewide guidance

The Pennington County Board of Commissioners voted April 30 to restore agricultural classification for a property whose owner raises and breeds horses, siding with commissioners who argued the county's narrow administrative interpretation excluded traditional livestock.

Shannon Champion, an Equalization Office supervisor, said county protocol had treated horses differently because county guidance emphasized crops, food or fiber production. Owner Scott Karen and several commissioners disagreed, citing South Dakota statutory references that include horses as livestock for branding and regulatory purposes.

"South Dakota codified law 40 15 1.3," the chair read into the record, "explicitly defines horses as livestock along with cattle, sheep, swine, goats, and buffalo." Commissioners and staff also discussed the Department of Revenue flowchart used for classification and noted that many county assessors in the state told staff they did not grant ag status for horses in their counties.

Commissioner Durer said the key question should be whether the animals are part of a breeding operation intended for profit. After discussion and an amendment to a motion (which set the structure/land numbers to the 2025 ag assessment levels), the board approved keeping the ag classification and asked staff to prepare consistent guidance and to identify whether a case law precedent or state-level decision is needed.

Separately, the board approved ag classification requests from the Crow Creek Sioux Tribe and related holdings (tribal parcels where haying, buffalo restoration and fenced pasture were documented) after brief presentations by tribal representatives and their counsel. Staff said parcel IDs and exact ag valuations would be confirmed in the minutes.

The actions preserve county practice for these parcels pending follow-up: staff will collect statutory references, the Department of Revenue guidance, and prepare a recommended county policy for commissioners to review.