Commission adds security recommendation and orders follow-up for fire‑damaged Iconic Apartments on South 1st

Farrah Presley, investigator with Austin Development Services, presented a returning case for 4313 South 1st Street (known locally as Iconic Apartments). Presley said the structure suffered multiple fires, remains fire‑damaged and dangerous, and that a previous October 2025 repair order had not been satisfied. Staff told the commission civil penalties had accrued to $18,714.29 and recommended modifying the prior order from repair to demolition while affirming the assessed penalty amount and stopping continued accrual.

Grant Pringler, attorney for the owner (Austin Multifamily LLC), asked the commission for additional time, citing two recent fires, ongoing insurance claims and litigation and the need for the insurer’s permission before disturbing the site. "To order a demolition today would not allow for a reasonable amount of time to assess and rectify the damage," Pringler said, asking for 90 or more days so the owner could present demolition permits or a timeline.

Neighbors living next door described recurring trespass, squatters, vandalism, and safety threats they said have continued since earlier fires. One neighbor said the site had become "a scene from the walking dead" and reported that squatters had created access to adjacent yards and harassed contractors.

Commissioners discussed options including demolition, continuing penalties, and measures to secure the site while insurance matters are resolved. Staff and counsel briefed the commission on statutory limits, including that the commission may extend compliance time up to 90 days with adequate documentation. The owner representatives said they were willing to secure fencing and to arrange for security contractors and asked for time to produce a full plan.

The commission adopted staff’s findings and the recommended order and added a unanimous recommendation that the owner obtain a new criminal‑trespass notice and secure the property with on‑site personnel from 6 p.m. to 6 a.m. The commission also affirmed the accrued civil penalty amount of $18,714.29 (which staff said would be capped if a demolition order were adopted). The vote on the adopted motion was unanimous.

Staff said they would continue monitoring and that any further enforcement action could follow if security, fencing, or progress on insurance and permitting is not demonstrated.