On March 18, 2026 the Rochester City Council Public Safety Committee discussed concerns about downtown bicycle lanes and agreed to move the item out of committee for further review by professional staff rather than taking immediate action.
DPW representative Miss Norris told the committee the downtown bike lanes and striping date to 2018 and that Federal Highway Administration guidance recommends a combined parking-and-bike-lane width of about 13 feet to reduce dooring risks. "Based off of the design widths shown, the combined width along Main Street is over 15 feet," Miss Norris said, adding that those locations meet the cited guidance.
The nut of the debate was whether design or user behavior is the safety risk. Councilor Horn raised neighborhood reports that specific segments feel dangerous — citing areas where lanes split or where a bike lane sits toward the middle of traffic — and asked staff and police to weigh in. The Deputy Chief said police reviewed two years of bicycle-crash data citywide and found "a total of 35 crashes" over that period and stated that "none of them were related to any of these bike lanes," while cautioning that absence of data does not prove safety.
Committee members also noted anecdotal input from constituents: one councillor said a constituent had written asking that the lanes not be removed because they personally use them. A committee member moved to take the bike-lanes item out of committee for further work by staff; members later agreed the item would be taken out of committee and handled by council without a formal roll-call vote. The chair said, "we won't continue the motion, but it will be taken out of committee and not brought up in future meetings."
The committee did not direct a specific engineering change and emphasized that DPW and police should continue monitoring, collect more data where possible, and return with recommendations. Next steps identified in the meeting: continued monitoring, further data collection on bike-lane usage and crashes, and staff-led design review before any repainting or configuration changes.
The Public Safety Committee meeting recessed after other agenda items; no formal vote tally was recorded on the bike-lane motion.