Residents and council split over funding for Old Everett High School as insurance request passes

Debate over the future of the Old Everett High School dominated public comments and council discussion Tuesday, as residents urged demolition and reallocation of funds while the council moved multi-step review of borrowing and insurance costs.

Public speakers described the building as a recurring expense and a 'money pit.' John Popolo urged the council to "immediately vacate the old high school without further delay and tear this building down as was originally promised," saying continued investment is fiscally irresponsible.

The council referred an order requesting approval to borrow $11,400,000 for improvements at the Old Everett High School to the Committee on Ways and Means and asked the administration to bring CFO and facilities staff to committee for detail and context.

At the same meeting the council approved a $270,000 appropriation from free cash to cover increased insurance costs related to the Old High School and a new fire boat. City officials explained the prior insurer dropped coverage because of roof and electrical problems. "The insurance company took it off the...general liability because of the roof issues," the city solicitor said when describing why the city had to seek replacement coverage at higher cost.

Councilors asked for a tour of the building and a clearer accounting of maintenance, utilities and prior appropriations before allocating larger sums. Several members said they want to see the administration's long-term plan for school facilities and whether funds might better relieve overcrowding at other schools.

Next steps: The $11.4 million borrowing request will be studied by Ways and Means with invited administration witnesses; the council has asked for facility tours of the old high school and Pope John to inform future appropriations.