Board rebuffs STA request to reopen bus contract amid performance concerns

District officials told the board a written request from STA — the district’s current student-transportation contractor under a multi‑year agreement — asked the district to consider reopening the contract to address market conditions affecting driver recruitment and pay. The letter proposed reconsidering pricing and potentially negotiating on items such as routing or vehicle types.

Board members responded strongly. Several directors said STA has a record of underperformance in recent years and questioned why the district should grant additional funds while contractual obligations have not been consistently met. One board member said the district could secure substitute services and pursue the contractor for damages if the company failed to provide service, while several others urged a performance‑based approach if any negotiations were to proceed.

Administrators said STA’s request was driven by local market RFP results in neighboring districts showing higher per‑run pricing, and they reported examples of comparable contracts returning significantly higher bids. Administrators also noted the district is in an advantageous contractual position (a 7‑year contract) but said the board could consider options that condition extra payments on improved on‑time performance and driver retention benchmarks.

Some board members advocated a firm stance that the district should not renegotiate mid-contract unless STA demonstrates improved performance; others asked staff to draft a written reply and explore options. Administration and legal counsel said they will review the company’s letter, possible contractual remedies, and performance data to report back to the board.