Pete's Garage requests lower insurance limits; Scranton board seeks verification before acting

Pete's Garage has asked the Scranton School District to amend its transportation contract for a third time to lower the excess umbrella insurance requirement from $10 million to $4 million, citing an insurer market retreat that has made coverage harder and more expensive to obtain.

Attorney Freund summarized a letter from counsel for Pete's Garage and said the board is under no legal obligation to accept the request; he described the proposal as a potential good‑faith accommodation to keep the contract operational. The firm’s agent, according to the letter read into the record, provided a list of neighboring districts and the carriers approached; the solicitor and business office noted variation in umbrella limits across nearby districts, from $1 million single limit up to $10 million umbrella in isolated cases.

Pat Laffey and the solicitor told the board they had not been able to verify all comparators in time for the meeting and that Dunmore’s umbrella was reported inconsistently in the materials provided. Directors pressed for evidence from insurers showing denials or unacceptable premium quotes, and asked administration to verify whether lowering insured limits would impair the district’s financial position or expose it to liability. Solicitor Freund said reducing the limit "does not affect the district financially" in the sense that contractor liability rests with the vendor, but acknowledged directors’ concerns about precedent and the optics of repeatedly amending signed contracts. Several directors said the district should not create a standard that invites other vendors to seek similar amendments without clear criteria.

Superintendent Keating and staff recommended that the board base any decision on whether students would be impacted (for example, loss of vehicles or routes), and asked the board to authorize administration to obtain denials from carriers, confirm peer district practices, and determine whether Pete's Garage’s participation is contingent on the change. Board members also asked for the financial consequences (estimated 30% premium increases cited by counsel) and any carrier denial letters to be provided before any vote.

No amendment was approved at the meeting; staff will return with carrier documentation, verified comparators and an analysis of transportation continuity risk.