Council weighs city hall renovation options as CIP shows multimillion‑dollar needs

City staff presented Lock Haven’s six‑year Capital Improvement Program on Feb. 21 and led a sustained council discussion about how to address renovation needs for the century‑old city hall.

Staff described three options for city hall funding and delivery: (1) borrow funds and pursue a Commonwealth RACP (Redevelopment Assistance Capital Program) grant to cover most costs (staff estimated a potential $2.5 million grant award but noted that only a small fraction of RACP project requests statewide are ultimately funded); (2) borrow and reduce professional‑contract costs by doing more work with city employees to lower construction bids; or (3) explore a private developer building city hall and leasing space to the city over a multi‑decade term.

Staff said, under a borrowing-plus‑RACP scenario, there is a roughly $1.6 million unfunded gap for city hall. Councilors asked staff to provide: a ten‑year maintenance and general‑upkeep cost history for the building, debt‑service scenarios for borrowing, likely lease terms and maintenance responsibilities under a developer‑built model, and developer cost estimates for a build/lease approach. Several members emphasized the need for clear cost certainty before committing to borrowing.

Council also discussed systemwide infrastructure needs shown in the CIP, including staff estimates that full replacement over 30 years would imply annual targets roughly in the range of $1.4M for stormwater, $2.0M for water and $1.1M for sewer. Staff scheduled a presentation on a proposed stormwater management fee for the second meeting in March and further water‑fund budget discussions in May.

Next steps: staff will obtain developer cost information, compile a ten‑year maintenance spending history, model debt‑service and lease scenarios, and return to council with comparative analyses.