Senate adopts substitute to child‑custody bill after stakeholder revisions focused on safety and expert qualifications

Senator McHale presented a fifth substitute to House Bill 272 on Feb. 29, 2024, explaining that the changes were the product of extensive stakeholder engagement, including work with Representative Cutler, the courts, victim advocates and medical professionals.

Sponsor remarks listed four focal points: child safety, expert testimony (with training in domestic violence for custody evaluators), safe therapy and child-abuse training for involved professionals. McHale said the substitute ensures courts and evaluators have clearer guidance and preserves judicial discretion where appropriate.

The sponsor cited letters of support and input from the Utah Medical Association, the Utah chapter of the American Academy of Pediatrics, Prevent Child Abuse Utah and a forensic-services specialist at the University of Utah as evidence of broad stakeholder involvement. Senators offered brief questions; sponsor said the substitute was a targeted clarification and not intended to unduly restrict courts.

The floor adopted the substitute and returned the bill to the House for further processing (Senate roll-call language recorded broadly as favorable during the floor action). The sponsor emphasized the bill’s child-safety orientation and asked colleagues for support as a product of compromise and stakeholder negotiation.