Commission continues contested Guerrero Street rear‑stair reconstruction to Jan. 25 for field verification

A public‑initiated discretionary review and variance for 1153 Guerrero Street — a request to reconstruct a three‑story enclosed rear stair and porch at an 1885 historic building — was continued to Jan. 25 after competing testimony raised concerns about the accuracy of submitted plans and the safety of existing temporary shoring.

David Winslow (staff architect) and the project sponsor described the permit history and noted existing notice(s) of violation. A nearby owner (Doctor requester) presented photographs and detailed testimony alleging structural inadequacy, lead paint hazards, and that some plans relied on work signed by an engineer whose license was later revoked. The sponsor argued inspections and permit sign‑offs had occurred and submitted DBI inspection records.

Given the conflicting evidence, the commission directed the Planning Department and the Department of Building Inspection to perform an on‑site verification of existing conditions and plan accuracy; commissioners emphasized that repairs are needed but should proceed only on the basis of accurate, stamped plans. The commission continued the item to Jan. 25 and requested staff report back on field findings and any required plan revisions.