Neighbors urge Board of Appeals to deny Fourth Floor permit for Irving Street project

The San Francisco Board of Appeals convened on July 4, 2025, to address a contentious issue regarding a proposed development at 4326 Irving Street. The meeting featured public comments from residents concerned about the construction of a fourth floor on the property, which they argue violates prior agreements made with the developers.

The session began with a resident expressing support for the complaints raised by neighbors Barbara and Larry Delaney regarding the project. Following this, Barry Gurden, a local resident, presented his case against the development. Gurden, along with his wife, Dr. Rita J. Jeremy, urged the Board to deny the permit for the additional floor, citing a previous agreement made with the developers last April. This agreement, they claimed, explicitly stated that no fourth floor would be constructed, a commitment they allege the developers have since disregarded.

Gurden emphasized the importance of trust within the community, questioning the reliability of developers who do not honor their commitments. He noted that the adjacent neighbors had attempted to reach a compromise with the developers, as suggested by the San Francisco Planning Commission, but felt that their efforts were met with noncompliance from the developers.

The discussion highlighted the broader implications of trust and accountability in neighborhood developments, as residents expressed their frustration over what they perceive as a breach of agreement. The meeting concluded with the Board considering the residents' concerns, with further deliberations expected on the matter.

As the Board of Appeals continues to review the situation, the outcome will likely impact not only the proposed development at 4326 Irving Street but also the dynamics of future negotiations between developers and community members in San Francisco.