Mary Kate Bacalau urges San Francisco to reconsider nonprofit fundraising rules

Mary Kate Bacalau, director of external affairs at Compass Family Services, voiced strong opposition during a recent San Francisco government meeting to a proposed measure that could jeopardize the financial stability of nonprofits serving the homeless. Bacalau, who also co-chairs the Homeless Emergency Service Providers Association (HESPA), emphasized the critical role of public officials in supporting nonprofit fundraising efforts, particularly for organizations that serve marginalized communities disproportionately affected by homelessness.

Bacalau argued that allowing public officials to accept free tickets to nonprofit fundraisers is essential for fostering relationships and encouraging community support. She highlighted that government contracts often cover only a fraction of the costs incurred by nonprofits, leaving them to rely heavily on private donations. "Public officials attending these events can significantly boost our fundraising efforts," she stated, underscoring the importance of their presence in advocating for essential services like shelter and mental health support.

The proposed measure also raised concerns about overly broad definitions of "restricted sources," which could impose civil and criminal liabilities on individuals engaging in policy advocacy without any financial benefit. Bacalau warned that this could deter community members from participating in nonprofit boards and advocacy efforts, ultimately undermining civic engagement. "We need to target those who intend to commit bribery, not penalize those who are simply trying to support a human right to housing," she asserted.

Additionally, Bacalau criticized the lack of a minimum value for gifts, arguing that everyday gestures, such as buying coffee or giving holiday cards, should not be criminalized. She drew parallels to the chilling effects of past regulations that discouraged vulnerable populations from accessing necessary services due to fear of penalties.

As the meeting progressed, Bacalau reiterated the unique challenges faced by nonprofits in the health and homeless services sector, calling for a more nuanced approach to regulation that recognizes their vital role in the community. "We need public officials to partner with us to raise private revenues to support our essential programs," she concluded, emphasizing the urgent need for collaboration in addressing homelessness in San Francisco.