San Francisco Board denies neighboring stair permit amidst ownership dispute

The San Francisco Board of Appeals convened on July 4, 2025, to address several significant matters, including appeals related to building permits and property alterations. The meeting highlighted the complexities of property rights and the implications of building regulations in the city.

One of the primary discussions centered on an appeal regarding a permit issued for alterations at 792 Hayes Street. The appellant, Zalan Le, argued that the permit was granted based on misrepresentation, as the staircase in question was located on her property, not that of the permit holder, Pat Deanda. Le presented evidence indicating that the staircase had been built for her property and that she had already obtained a permit for its repair. The Board heard concerns about the legality of the permit issued to Deanda, with Deputy Zoning Administrator Tina Tam confirming that the stairs appeared to be on Le's property based on aerial photographs.

The Board also discussed the implications of a firewall that would be required if the stairs were to be rebuilt, which could block access to Deanda's property. Inspector Green noted that there were two permits issued for the same staircase, raising questions about the validity of the permits and the potential for neighborly disputes.

After deliberation, the Board unanimously voted to grant Le's appeal, effectively denying the permit for Deanda. This decision underscored the Board's commitment to ensuring that building permits are issued correctly and that property rights are respected.

In another matter, the Board reviewed an appeal concerning alterations at 3421-3425 Twentieth Street. The permit holder had submitted revised plans to address previous concerns raised by the Board. The revisions included modifications to the kitchen layout and the addition of laundry facilities in each unit. The Planning Department indicated that the revised plans complied with zoning regulations, and the Board voted to grant the appeal, contingent upon the adoption of the revised plans.

Overall, the meeting highlighted the ongoing challenges faced by property owners in navigating the complexities of building regulations in San Francisco, as well as the Board's role in mediating disputes and ensuring compliance with city codes. The Board's decisions reflect a careful consideration of both property rights and community standards, aiming to foster a harmonious living environment in the city.