David Armour Architecture proposes new family home with ADU at 136 Delmar Street

In a recent San Francisco government meeting, a proposal for a new residential project at 136 Del Mar Street sparked significant discussion among city officials and community members. The project, presented by local architect David Armour and his wife Lisa, aims to replace a dilapidated structure with a modern family-sized home and an accessory dwelling unit (ADU). This initiative reflects ongoing efforts to address housing needs in the city while preserving its architectural heritage.

The Armour family, who have lived in the current home for several years, described the extensive challenges they faced due to the building's deteriorating condition, including chronic foundation issues and mold growth. They emphasized that maintaining the existing structure would require a substantial financial investment, which they deemed impractical. Their proposal seeks to create a new home that not only accommodates their family but also includes a rental unit to support multi-generational living and provide additional income.

The design of the new building has been carefully crafted to align with the character of the Upper Haight neighborhood. The proposed structure will feature a three-story layout with a gabled roof, allowing for natural light while minimizing visual impact on neighboring properties. The Armours have engaged with the community throughout the design process, incorporating feedback from neighbors to refine their plans. Notably, the design includes setbacks and mass reductions to address concerns about the building's height and bulk.

Community response has been largely positive, with several neighbors expressing support for the project. However, some concerns were raised during the public comment period, particularly regarding the potential impact on adjacent properties. One neighbor, Ted Markham, voiced apprehension about the project's mass and its implications for his living environment. He highlighted ongoing discussions with the Armours about specific design elements, particularly the proposed height of the new structure.

The project has received backing from city planning staff, who recommend its approval based on compliance with residential design guidelines. As the city grapples with housing shortages and the need for diverse living options, this proposal represents a significant step toward addressing these challenges while honoring the unique architectural landscape of San Francisco.

As the commission prepares to make a decision, the outcome of this proposal could set a precedent for future residential developments in the area, balancing the need for new housing with the preservation of community character. The Armours remain hopeful for a favorable resolution, aiming to create a home that reflects both their family's needs and the historical context of their neighborhood.