Supervisor Chan proposes Good and Clean Government Act to reform city commission appointments

The San Francisco Board of Supervisors convened on July 4, 2025, to discuss a significant charter amendment aimed at reforming the appointment process for various city commissions. This proposed change, known as the Good and Clean Government Act, seeks to split the power of appointments between the Mayor and the Board of Supervisors for key bodies, including the Airport Commission, Arts Commission, and Health Commission, among others.

Supervisor Chan, the measure's primary sponsor, emphasized the need for increased accountability and transparency within city government. She highlighted that the current system has fostered a culture of cronyism and inefficiency, which has been corroborated by federal investigations and audits. Chan argued that the amendment would restore independence to the city administrator's office, allowing it to focus on improving city services without political interference.

The proposed amendment also aims to define the functions of departments under the city administrator's oversight through public ordinances, ensuring that the public has a voice in how city services are managed. Chan noted that this reform is not a "silver bullet" but a crucial step toward enhancing the city's governance structure.

During the meeting, several supervisors expressed their support for the amendment, citing the importance of having diverse representation in city commissions. They argued that shared appointment authority would lead to better oversight and decision-making that reflects the values of San Francisco's communities.

Public comments were mixed, with many residents voicing strong support for the amendment, citing the need for reform in a system perceived as overly controlled by the Mayor. Others raised concerns about the potential for increased bureaucracy and questioned whether the changes would genuinely improve governance or simply shift power dynamics within the city.

As the discussion continues, the Board of Supervisors will consider amendments and public feedback before potentially placing the charter amendment on the ballot for voter approval. The outcome of this initiative could significantly reshape the governance landscape in San Francisco, aiming to enhance public trust and service delivery in a city grappling with complex challenges.