Board approves removal and replacement of 19 ficus trees near San Francisco library

The July 4, 2025, meeting of the San Francisco Board of Appeals focused on the contentious issue of tree removals and replacements at the main library, particularly concerning the Ficus trees. The meeting began with a review of the previous decisions made regarding the urban forestry plan, which included a vote to continue appeals related to the replacement tree species and project timelines.

Lance Karnes, an appellant, presented his case, emphasizing the need for thorough inspections of the trees, particularly after a recent incident where a tree fell and caused damage. He criticized the Bureau of Urban Forestry (BUF) for not adequately inspecting the trees and for rushing to remove them without sufficient evidence of their condition. Karnes highlighted that previous inspections had not included all trees, raising concerns about the safety and management of the remaining trees.

In response, Mr. Buck from BUF provided a detailed overview of the bureau's approach to managing the Ficus trees, citing historical issues with their structural integrity. He explained that the decision to remove the trees was based on safety concerns following the recent failure of one tree, which confirmed their fears about the remaining trees' stability. Buck acknowledged the previous compromise to retain some trees but stated that the recent failure necessitated a reevaluation of their safety.

The discussion revealed a significant divide between the appellants and the BUF regarding the management of the trees. Appellants expressed frustration over the perceived disregard for previous agreements and the potential loss of urban greenery. They argued for a more measured approach that would allow for the retention of healthy trees while addressing safety concerns.

The meeting concluded with a call for further discussions on the replacement plan, which includes planting new species that can thrive in the urban environment. The BUF committed to working closely with the library and the community to ensure that the replacement trees are suitable and that the process is transparent.

Overall, the meeting underscored the ongoing challenges of urban forestry management in San Francisco, balancing public safety with environmental stewardship and community needs. The board's next steps will involve continued dialogue with stakeholders to refine the tree management strategy moving forward.