Todd Presley contests awning permit for Lost Resort due to noise complaints

The San Francisco City Council meeting on July 4, 2025, focused on a contentious appeal regarding a patio awning permit for The Lost Resort, a long-standing bar and restaurant. The meeting featured discussions from both the appellant, Todd Presley, and the permit holder, Mr. Valentine, highlighting concerns over noise pollution and community relations.

Presley argued for the revocation of the awning permit, citing increased noise levels that disrupt his home life. He detailed modifications made to the bar's patio since new ownership took over in 2019, including the installation of a mesh wall and a new awning that he claims funnels noise towards neighboring homes. Presley presented photographs to illustrate the changes and emphasized that the noise is audible inside his home seven days a week.

In response, Mr. Valentine defended the awning, stating that it was necessary for outdoor seating during rainy months and that the bar has been a community fixture for nearly a century. He noted that no other neighbors have raised concerns about noise and expressed a willingness to work with Presley to mitigate any issues. Valentine mentioned that various city agencies, including the Alcoholic Beverage Control (ABC) and the Entertainment Commission, have conducted unannounced visits and found no violations regarding noise levels.

The discussion underscored the ongoing challenge of balancing business operations with residential peace in urban settings. The council members acknowledged the complexities of noise management in a city environment, recognizing the need for continued dialogue between local businesses and residents. The outcome of the appeal remains to be determined, with potential implications for both the bar's operations and neighborhood relations.