San Francisco Board proposes increased fines for illegal housing developments

The San Francisco County government meeting on July 4, 2025, focused on proposed legislation aimed at addressing violations of planning and building codes, particularly concerning a controversial development project in District 9. The meeting highlighted the case of a developer at 2861 San Bruno Avenue, who exceeded their permitted units and failed to provide adequate safety measures, resulting in unsafe living conditions for tenants.

The proposed legislation seeks to significantly increase penalties for developers who violate building codes. Currently, the maximum fine is $250 per day, but the new legislation would raise this to $1,000 per day. Additionally, it would impose a one-time fee of $250,000 for any dwelling unit that is illegally added or demolished, and a $500,000 fee for historical buildings that are damaged or demolished. This change aims to create a stronger deterrent against non-compliance, as the current penalties allow developers to profit from illegal units while facing minimal consequences.

Audrey Maloney from the Planning Department supported the legislation, noting that both the Historic Preservation Commission and the Planning Commission had previously recommended modifications to the draft. One key amendment discussed was the requirement for the Planning Department to record notices of violation against property titles, ensuring that potential buyers are aware of any outstanding penalties or violations before purchasing a property.

Public comments during the meeting reflected support for the increased penalties, with one speaker emphasizing the need for the Planning Commission to utilize its legislative authority to adjust demolition thresholds to better protect existing housing.

The meeting concluded with a commitment to further refine the legislation, with additional amendments expected to be discussed in future sessions. The proposed changes represent a significant step towards holding developers accountable and ensuring safer living conditions for residents in San Francisco.