Community members oppose Cherry Street homeless shelter citing crime and safety concerns

The Tompkins County Legislature convened on December 4, 2024, to address several pressing community issues, including the proposed acquisition of property for a homeless shelter and public safety concerns.

The meeting began with public comments, where a resident expressed distress over a year-long ban affecting local stores, pleading for understanding and assistance from the legislature. The individual emphasized the need for community support and communication, highlighting feelings of neglect.

Following this, Zach Wynne presented a strong opposition to the resolution for acquiring property on Cherry Street for a permanent homeless shelter. He argued that the location is unsuitable due to its proximity to existing encampments and local businesses, which he believes could exacerbate crime and safety issues. Wynne criticized the proposed low-barrier approach of the shelter, suggesting it would enable drug use and hinder recovery efforts for those experiencing homelessness. He urged the legislature to reconsider the acquisition, advocating for a site further from downtown that could better serve the homeless population without negatively impacting the surrounding community.

Irene Weiser, a former town board member, also addressed the legislature, focusing on the safety of a local resident, Amanda David. Weiser called for the sheriff's department to resume patrols near David's home to ensure her safety, echoing concerns raised by others regarding the challenges she has faced.

The discussions highlighted significant community concerns regarding homelessness, public safety, and the need for thoughtful planning in addressing these issues. The legislature is expected to consider the feedback from residents as they deliberate on the proposed property acquisition and related safety measures in future meetings.