Neighborhood debates modern home design amid height concerns

In a recent government meeting, the Upper Arlington Board reviewed a variance request for a modern home proposed at 3134 Asbury Drive, which exceeds the city's 22-foot height limit for new constructions. The request is part of the city's neighbor compatibility ordinance aimed at ensuring new homes blend with existing neighborhoods.

The proposed home stands at 31 feet, prompting scrutiny regarding its architectural style and materials. The city employs a third-party architect to assess such applications, and while the architect deemed the scale and massing acceptable, concerns were raised about the use of large panel HardiePlank siding, which is less common in the area and perceived as more commercial.

The applicant, Andrew Sarooff, defended the design, stating that the two-story home aims to harmonize with neighboring structures, many of which reach heights of 30 to 35 feet. He emphasized the use of sloped roofs and materials that resonate with local character, such as stone and stucco, while committing to warmer color schemes.

However, community member Jeanie Ferguson expressed strong opposition, arguing that the proposed design starkly contrasts with the existing homes on Asbury Drive. She highlighted the importance of maintaining architectural consistency and compatibility within the neighborhood, suggesting that the design's modern elements could disrupt the area's character.

The board acknowledged the concerns and discussed the possibility of further collaboration with the applicant to refine the design, particularly regarding color schemes and material choices. The outcome of this variance request remains pending as the board considers the balance between modern architectural expression and neighborhood harmony.