Proposed changes spark debate over historic property design

In a recent government meeting, significant revisions to the construction plans for a new development on Avenida Menendez were discussed, focusing on the use of materials and design elements that align with historical preservation standards. The proposed changes include replacing the cement block construction of the east property wall with exposed coquina, a local shell stone, which will remain unfinished. This decision aims to enhance the aesthetic appeal of the property while maintaining historical integrity.

The interior courtyard will feature clay brick pavers, particularly in the eastern section facing the entrance, and the loggia flooring of the Espinosa Sanchez house will also utilize clay pavers. These materials were chosen to reflect the colonial architectural style of the area, as brick pavers were deemed more appropriate than previously considered options.

Additionally, the construction plans have been updated to include a wooden lintel over the gates instead of a coquina lintel, a change that was highlighted in the meeting. The board reviewed the updated plans and discussed the historical context of coquina walls, noting that they were traditionally plastered for waterproofing and aesthetic purposes.

The meeting concluded with staff recommending that the board approve the revised plans, asserting that they are compatible with the Historic Preservation Guidelines and meet the Secretary of Interior Standards for Rehabilitation. Alternatively, the board could choose to continue the discussion, allowing the applicant time to modify the design if deemed incompatible with historical standards. The outcome of this meeting will play a crucial role in shaping the development's integration into the historic fabric of St. Augustine.