House Color Controversy Sparks Debate in Historic District

In a recent government meeting, the Board discussed an application for a new paint color scheme for a historic property located at 87 South High Street, characterized by its Greek Revival architecture. The current color scheme features a body color of Dorian Gray and trim in Tricorn Black. The applicant proposed to change the body color to Iron Ore, a darker hue, while retaining the existing black trim.

The application was brought before the Board because the proposed color does not align with the preapproved paint colors established for the district, which typically favor lighter shades reminiscent of Greek temples. The Board acknowledged that while the new color is not administratively approvable, they have the discretion to consider alternatives.

During the meeting, the applicant, Shannon Hostel, expressed her desire to maintain the Iron Ore color, arguing that it enhances the historic charm of the neighborhood and blends well with adjacent properties, which feature a variety of colors. She noted that the darker color has received positive feedback from neighbors, contributing to the aesthetic appeal of the area.

Board members engaged in a thorough discussion, weighing the merits of the proposed color against the historical guidelines. Some members expressed concerns that the darker color might obscure the architectural details of the home, while others felt it could still fit within the character of the district. Ultimately, the Board faced a decision between two options: either requiring the applicant to select a color from the preapproved list or approving the proposed color with a stipulation to complete the painting within 30 days.

After deliberation, the Board voted on the first option, which would require the applicant to repaint using an approved color. The motion passed, indicating a preference for adherence to the established guidelines over the proposed deviation. The applicant was encouraged to work with staff to select a suitable color that aligns with the historical context of the property.