Historic Building Set for Major Facade Revamp

In a recent meeting, the New York City Landmarks Preservation Commission reviewed a proposal for significant exterior alterations to 900 Broadway, a commercial building located in the Ladies Mile Historic District. Designed by the renowned architectural firm McKim, Mead and White and constructed in 1886, the building has undergone various modifications over the years, including a notable alteration in 1905.

The proposed changes include the installation of awnings with closed sides, security cameras, and a new access ramp with railings, as well as the replacement of non-compliant doors and the addition of illuminated signage. The architect, Anton Christel of Christel Studios, emphasized that the design aims to reflect the building's historical character while enhancing its functionality.

During the presentation, the team highlighted the historical context of awnings in the district, noting that enclosed awnings were common in the late 19th century. They provided visual evidence from historic photographs to support their proposal, arguing that the new awnings would evoke a traditional aesthetic appropriate for the building's architecture.

Commissioners expressed mixed feelings about the enclosed awnings, with some advocating for a more streamlined design that would complement the building's robust architectural features. Concerns were raised regarding the ramp's visibility and the potential for it to detract from the building's historic detailing. However, the overall sentiment leaned towards support for the proposal, with many commissioners acknowledging the careful consideration given to maintaining the building's historical integrity.

The Victorian Society of New York also voiced support for the changes, praising the proposed signage and the reversible nature of the ramp installation. They did, however, suggest that the awning frames could be less rigid to better align with the building's historic character.

As the discussion concluded, the commission moved to close the hearing, with a recommendation for approval pending further refinement of the awning design. The outcome reflects a broader commitment to preserving the architectural heritage of the Ladies Mile Historic District while accommodating modern needs.