Key West commission votes 4–3 to let city attorney negotiate separation with city manager after heated debate

The City Commission voted 4–3 to direct the city attorney to negotiate an amicable separation agreement with City Manager Brian Barroso and to report back at the Oct. 1, 2026 meeting. The measure was introduced by Vice Mayor Lee and moved for approval by Commissioner Matt Haskell; Commissioner Massacott seconded the motion.

Public speakers urged caution. Greg Lloyd, a resident and former planning‑board member, told the commission: "We should not be negotiating a severance package with city manager Bridal Barroso at this time, not while serious questions concerning his tenure remain unresolved and an independent investigation completed." Margaret Romero, another resident, urged the commission to respect that the city operates under a city‑manager form of government and to try to work things out. City Manager Brian Barroso spoke to the commission, calling the problem a personality conflict and defending his performance while saying repeated investigations have taken a toll. The roll call on the resolution recorded four yes votes and three no votes; the motion passed.