HARC approves Key West balcony and pool project after removing circular window

The Historic Architectural Review Commission approved a renovation that adds a second‑floor front balcony over an existing carport and a rear pool, but commissioners required removal of a proposed circular front window. Carlos Rojas, the project's architect, described the design as a modest, neighborhood‑compatible change that adds a front porch where one was missing: “I really like the round window… I’m a sailor, so as much as I can influence nautical architecture in Key West, I’m all for it.”

Staff planner Matthew told the commission the house and carport appear non‑historic on Sanborn maps and photos and that the project generally meets district guidelines; staff recommended denying the circular window because it does not match window types typically approved in the district. Commissioner Osborne moved to approve the project subject to the staff recommendation to remove the round window; the motion carried unanimously after roll call. The commission also approved a single reading for the limited demolition necessary to fill the porch area and confirmed that guardrail details will be reviewed at permitting.