HARC approves replacement of mixed stained glass at Windsor Lane church, asks to retain historic panels

Seth Neal, representing St. Mary’s (Star of the Sea), asked the commission to allow the replacement of 36 choir‑loft panes where only about 8 amber 'majestic' panels remain; the applicant offered a sample of the proposed replacement. Staff and commissioners acknowledged the majestic pattern is no longer made and urged retention of surviving historic panels while allowing the closest available textured/impact glass for storm hardening and visual consistency.

Matthew, staff planner, said research shows the original Swindle Brothers’ "majestic" amber is no longer produced and that the closest replication should be used. Commissioners supported a compromise: approve replacement for the mixed‑pane sash locations to improve storm resilience but request donation or archiving of any salvaged historic glass. The motion to approve the replacement work passed on roll call with the request that the applicant provide remaining historic panels to the city for archival purposes if possible.